Table 1

Description of the studies included in the analysis

AuthorImplantDiagnosisControlNPrimary outcome measures used
Kuslich1 BAK cagesSymptomatic discNone947Modified Prolo Scale
degeneration
Ray2 Ray threaded fusion cagesSymptomatic disc degenerationNone236Prolo Scale
Brantigan3 Brantigan I/F cagesSymptomatic disc degeneration with failed discectomyNone2215 point Likert scale for pain
Burkus4 InFUSE bone graft in tapered cagesSymptomatic disc degenerationAutogenous iliac crest bone graft in tapered cages143 Infuse; 136 autograftODI, back pain, leg pain, patient satisfaction, work status
Blumenthal5 CHARITÉ Artificial DiscSymptomatic disc degenerationALIF (BAK cages with iliac crest bone graft)205 CHARITÉ; 99 fusionVAS, ODI
Zigler6 and Synthes Spine7 (on FDA website)ProDisc-L Total Disc ReplacementSymptomatic disc degenerationCombined anterior/posterior instrumented fusion162 ProDisc-L; 80 fusionODI, VAS, satisfaction
Zucherman8 X-STOPNeurogenic intermittent claudication due to stenosisNon-operative care100 X-STOP; 91 controlZurich Claudication Questionnaire