Attachment and proliferation of osteoblasts and fibroblasts on biomaterials for orthopaedic use
Abstract
Using a variety of cell types, cell attachment and growth was studied on prospective (polyethersulphone (PES) and polyetheretherketone) and currently used (titanium 318 alloy, cobalt chrome molybdenum alloy and ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE)) orthopaedic biomaterials. Proliferation of fibroblasts and osteoblasts was measured using incorporation of tritiated thymidine into total DNA. Attachment of cells was assessed by indirect immunofluorescent labelling of vinculin, a component of the cell's focal adhesion plaque. The degree of cell attachment was quantified on the materials by determining the mean number of adhesion plaques and using an image analysis system to determine the mean total area of plaques per cell. Fibroblasts and osteoblasts responded differently to the materials tested. When grown on PES surfaces, rat tail fibroblasts synthesized significantly greater amounts of DNA than cells on all other surfaces, whilst fibroblasts on UHMWPE synthesized significantly less DNA than cells on all other materials. Interestingly, there was no significant difference between the amounts of DNA synthesized by osteoblasts grown on the various materials. Determination of the number of vinculin adhesion plaques per cell and the mean total area of the plaques per cell showed that the attachment of fibroblasts to UHMWPE was significantly reduced compared with other materials. In contrast there was no significant difference in the adhesion of osteoblasts to different materials. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) observations of cells on the materials correlated with the morphometric data. Cells with the greatest number and area of adhesion plaques were well spread and flattened whilst those with the least number of adhesion plaques were more rounded and less spread.
References (16)
- FB Bagambisa et al.
Preliminary studies on the phenomenological behaviour of osteoblasts cultured on hydroxyapatite ceramics
Biomaterials
(1990) - CW Archer et al.
Cell shape and cartilage differentiation of early chick limb bud cells in culture
Cell Differentiation
(1982) - JD Bobyn et al.
Histological comparison of biological fixation and bone modeling with canine and human porous-coated hip prostheses
- A Ben-Ze'ev
Animal cell shape changes and gene expression
Bioessays
(1991) - DJ McQuillan et al.
Proteoglycans synthesised by an osteoblast like cell line (UMR106.01)
Biochem J
(1991) - SC Manolagus et al.
1,25-Dihydroxyvitamin D3 receptor like macromolecule in rat osteogenic sarcoma cell lines
J Biol Chem
(1980) - PM Royce et al.
Fluorimetric determination of DNA in papain digests of cartilage, using ethidium bromide
Connective Tissue Res
(1979) - CP Cottril
A micromass culture analysis of limb development
Cited by (262)
In total knee arthroplasty (TKA), the mechanical mismatch between cobalt-chromium (CoCr) alloy tibial implant and bone has been implicated in stress shielding and subsequent implant failure and bone resorption. This study investigates the biomechanical advantages of poly-ether-ether-ketone (PEEK) tibial implant, which exhibit properties analogous to those of the surrounding bone. A finite element analysis (FEA) was employed to assess and compare the biomechanical performances of PEEK and CoCr tibial implants in patients with and without osteoporosis. Four FEA models were constructed with PEEK and CoCr alloy implants in normal and osteoporotic tibias. Based on previous literature and our clinical experience, stresses measurements were taken at 16 points on the tibial plateau and 8 points on the two surfaces which were 10 mm and 20 mm apart from the tibial plateau, with specific regions quantified for stress shielding. The results showed significant differences in stress distribution between PEEK and CoCr implants. The PEEK implants exhibited higher equivalent stresses on the tibial plateau in all models (normal bone: 0.22 ± 0.07 MPa vs. 0.13 ± 0.06 MPa, p < 0.01; osteoporotic bone: 0.39 ± 0.06 MPa vs. 0.17 ± 0.07 MPa, p < 0.01). In non-osteoporotic models, the mean equivalent stresses on proximal tibial surfaces were similarly elevated for PEEK implants (0.29 ± 0.13 MPa vs. 0.21 ± 0.08 MPa, p = 0.02). The CoCr implants demonstrated more stress shielding across all measured regions (tibial plateau: 23.47% vs. 2.73%; surface 1: 15.93% vs. 1.37%; surface 2: 10.71% vs. 6.56%). These disparities were even more pronounced in osteoporotic models in the CoCr group (tibial plateau: 32.50% vs. 8.36%). The maximum equivalent stresses on the tibial plateau further supported this trend (normal bone: 1.02 MPa vs. 0.52 MPa; osteoporotic bone: 1.43 MPa vs. 0.67 MPa). These data confirm the hypothesis that a PEEK tibial implant can reduce peri-prosthetic stress shielding, suggesting that PEEK implants have the capability to distribute loads more uniformly and maintain a closer approximation to physiological conditions.
A non local model for cell migration in response to mechanical stimuli
2024, Mathematical BiosciencesCell migration is one of the most studied phenomena in biology since it plays a fundamental role in many physiological and pathological processes such as morphogenesis, wound healing and tumorigenesis. In recent years, researchers have performed experiments showing that cells can migrate in response to mechanical stimuli of the substrate they adhere to. Motion towards regions of the substrate with higher stiffness is called durotaxis, while motion guided by the stress or the deformation of the substrate itself is called tensotaxis. Unlike chemotaxis (i.e. the motion in response to a chemical stimulus), these migratory processes are not yet fully understood from a biological point of view. In this respect, we present a mathematical model of single-cell migration in response to mechanical stimuli, in order to simulate these two processes. Specifically, the cell moves by changing its direction of polarization and its motility according to material properties of the substrate (e.g., stiffness) or in response to proper scalar measures of the substrate strain or stress. The equations of motion of the cell are non-local integro-differential equations, with the addition of a stochastic term to account for random Brownian motion. The mechanical stimulus to be integrated in the equations of motion is defined according to experimental measurements found in literature, in the case of durotaxis. Conversely, in the case of tensotaxis, substrate strain and stress are given by the solution of the mechanical problem, assuming that the extracellular matrix behaves as a hyperelastic Yeoh’s solid. In both cases, the proposed model is validated through numerical simulations that qualitatively reproduce different experimental scenarios.
Calcium carbonate particle synthesis in a confined and dynamically thinning layer on a spin-coater – In situ deposition for cell adhesion
2023, Materials Chemistry and PhysicsWe have designed a new method for the in situ synthesis of CaCO3 particles via spin-coating while simultaneously controlling their distribution on the surface. CaCO3 is synthesized by simultaneously adding CaCl2 and Na2CO3 solutions to a rotating surface on a spin-coater. During the transient liquid film evaporation on the spin-coater, as the film layer progressively thins, the CaCO3 particles nucleate and grow while confined within that thinning layer on the spin-coater. The evaporation of the volatile component increases the global concentration of solids, resulting in the deposition of precipitates (CaCO3 particles). The growth rate, particle size, and coverage were theoretically and experimentally analyzed by adjusting the process parameters, initial salt concentrations, rotational speed, and post-deposition treatment. Experimental findings indicated that increasing the rotational speed resulted in formation of smaller particle sizes, while the concentration of the precursors directly influenced the average diameter of the particles. Raman spectroscopy analysis demonstrated that vaterite particles synthesized from lower salt concentrations exhibited a more intense signal than those synthesized from higher salt concentrations. Furthermore, higher salt concentrations led to increased particle coverage, while higher rotational speeds resulted in decreased particle coverage on the substrate. We explored the potential of such coatings in biomedicine and tissue engineering by seeding MC3T3-E1 cells on the CaCO3 particle-coated glass substrates. Surfaces functionalized with CaCO3 particles exhibited enhanced cell proliferation and adhesion.
Fibroblast behavior on conventionally processed, milled, and printed occlusal device materials with different surface treatments
2023, Journal of Prosthetic DentistryOcclusal devices can be either conventionally processed, milled, or printed. However, little is known about the biocompatibility of 3D printing resin materials.
The purpose of this in vitro study was to compare the viability and morphology of human gingival fibroblast cells (HFG-1) after cultivation on conventionally processed, milled, and printed occlusal device materials with different surface treatments.
Disks of a conventionally processed (PalaXpress Clear [pP]), milled (Yamahachi PMMA Clear [sY]), and 2 different printed materials (Dental LT Clear Resin [aD]; Freeprint splint [aF]) were prepared. The surfaces of the specimens were finished by using 2 different treatments (unpolished and polished with P1200-grit silicon carbide paper). HGF-1 cells were cultivated on the specimens for 24 hours, and a viability assay was performed by using polystyrene disks as a control (n=9 disks per group). Cell morphology and the topography of the specimens were examined with scanning electron microscopy (n=3 disks per group). Two-way analysis of variance was applied to determine the effect of material and surface treatment followed by the post hoc Fisher least significant difference test (α=.05).
Overall, material (P<.001) and surface treatment (P<.001) significantly influenced the viability of HGF-1 cells. The viability of cells on all specimens displayed mean values between 0.85 and 1.01 compared with the control except for unpolished aD (0.00 ±0.07) and aF (0.02 ±0.05) that had only a few cells with a round shape.
The behavior of HGF-1 cells on conventionally processed and milled specimens was similar and not dependent on the surface treatment. Unpolished printed specimens had a cytotoxic effect. However, after polishing, cell behavior was similar to that of the conventionally processed and milled specimens.
3D printed zirconia dental implants with integrated directional surface pores combine mechanical strength with favorable osteoblast response
2022, Acta BiomaterialiaDental implants need to combine mechanical strength with promoted osseointegration. Currently used subtractive manufacturing techniques require a multi-step process to obtain a rough surface topography that stimulates osseointegration. Advantageously, additive manufacturing (AM) enables direct implant shaping with unique geometries and surface topographies. In this study, zirconia implants with integrated lamellar surface topography were additively manufactured by nano-particle ink-jetting. The ISO-14801 fracture load of as-sintered implants (516±39 N) resisted fatigue in 5–55 °C water thermo-cycling (631±134 N). Remarkably, simultaneous mechanical fatigue and hydrothermal aging at 90 °C significantly increased the implant strength to 909±280 N due to compressive stress generated at the seamless transition of the 30–40 µm thick, rough and porous surface layer to the dense implant core. This unique surface structure induced an elongated osteoblast morphology with uniform cell orientation and allowed for osteoblast proliferation, long-term attachment and matrix mineralization. In conclusion, the developed AM zirconia implants not only provided high long-term mechanical resistance thanks to the dense core along with compressive stress induced at the transition zone, but also generated a favorable osteoblast response owing to the integrated directional surface pores.
Zirconia ceramics are becoming the material of choice for metal-free dental implants, however significant efforts are required to obtain a rough/porous surface for enhanced osseointegration, along with the risk of surface delamination and/or microstructure variation. In this study, we addressed the challenge by additively manufacturing implants that seamlessly combine dense core with a porous surface layer. For the first time, a unique surface with a directional lamellar pore morphology was additively obtained. This AM implant also provided strength as strong as conventionally manufactured zirconia implants before and after long-term fatigue. Favorable osteoblast response was proved by in-vitro cell investigation. This work demonstrated the opportunity to AM fabricate novel ceramic implants that can simultaneously meet the mechanical and biological functionality requirements.
Human osteoblasts response to different dental implant abutment materials: An in-vitro study
2022, Dental MaterialsThis study aimed to investigate human osteoblasts (HOB) response towards different dental implant abutment materials.
Five dental implant abutment materials were investigated: (1) titanium (Ti), (2) titanium coated nitride (TiN), (3) cobalt chromium (CoCr), (4) zirconia (ZrO₂), and (5) modified polyether ether ketone (m-PEEK). HOBs were cultured, expanded, and seeded according to the supplier’s protocol (PromoCell, UK). Cell proliferation and cytotoxicity were evaluated at days 1, 3, 5, and 10 using Alamar Blue (alamarBlue) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) colorimetric assays. Data were analysed via two-way ANOVA, one-way ANOVA and Tukey’s post hoc test (significance was determined as p < 0.05 for all tests).
All the investigated materials showed high and comparable initial proliferation activities apart from ZrO₂ (46.92%), with P% of 79.91%, 68.77%, 73.20%, and 65.46% for Ti, TiN, CoCr, and m-PEEK, respectively. At day 10, all materials exhibited comparable and lower P% than day 1 apart from TiN (70.90%) with P% of 30.22%, 40.64%, 37.27%, and 50.65% for Ti, CoCr, ZrO₂, and m-PEEK, respectively. The cytotoxic effect of the investigated materials was generally low throughout the whole experiment. At day 10, the cytotoxicity % was 7.63%, 0.21%, 13.30%, 5.32%, 8.60% for Ti, TiN, CoCr, ZrO₂, and m-PEEK. The Two-way ANOVA and Tukey’s Multiple Comparison Method highlighted significant material and time effects on cell proliferation and cytotoxicity, and a significant interaction (p < 0.0001) between the tested materials. Notably, TiN and m-PEEK showed improved HOB proliferation activity and cytotoxic levels than the other investigated materials. In addition, a non-significant negative correlation between viability and cytotoxicity was found for all tested materials. Ti (p = 0.07), TiN (p = 0.28), CoCr (p = 0.15), ZrO₂ (p = 0.17), and m-PEEK (p = 0.12).
All the investigated materials showed excellent biocompatibility properties with more promising results for the newly introduced TiN and m-PEEK as alternatives to the traditionally used dental implant and abutment materials.