The objective of this study was to determine the relative mechanical properties of the cement-bone interface due to tensile or shear loading. Mechanical tests were performed on cement-bone specimens in tensile (n = 51) or shear (n = 55) test jigs under the displacement control at 1 mm/min until complete failure. Before testing, the quantity of bone interdigitated with the cement was determined and served as a covariate in the study. The apparent strength of the cement-bone interface was significantly higher (p < 0.0001) for the interface when loaded in shear (2.25 MPa) when compared to tensile loading (1.35 MPa). Significantly higher energies to failure (p < 0.0001) and displacement before failure (p < 0.01) were also determined for the shear specimens. The post-yield softening response was not different for the two test directions. The data obtained herein suggests that cement-bone interfaces with equal amounts of tensile and shear stress would be more likely to fail under tensile loading.